A Boy Named Sue

Now that I am a grandfather (the due date is in October) it is only appropriate that I start advising my daughter and her husband on names for my granddaughter or grandson.

Marion Tierney at the New York Times has an article about names. He writes in part:

[Johnny Cash] used “A Boy Named Sue” to present two hypotheses:

1. A child with an awful name might grow up to be a relatively normal adult.

2. The parent who inflicted the name does not deserve to be executed.

He goes on to say,

Studies showed that children with odd names got worse grades and were less popular than other classmates in elementary school. In college they were more likely to flunk out or become “psychoneurotic.” Prospective bosses spurned their résumés. They were overrepresented among emotionally disturbed children and psychiatric patients.

Some of these mental problems might have been genetic — what kind of parent picks a name like Golden Rule or Mary Mee? — but it was still bad news.

Today, though, the case for Mr. Cash’s theory looks much stronger, and I say this even after learning about Emma Royd and Post Office in a new book, “Bad Baby Names,” by Michael Sherrod and Matthew Rayback.

By scouring census records from 1790 to 1930, Mr. Sherrod and Mr. Rayback discovered Garage Empty, Hysteria Johnson, King Arthur, Infinity Hubbard, Please Cope, Major Slaughter, Helen Troy, several Satans and a host of colleagues to the famed Ima Hogg (including Ima Pigg, Ima Muskrat, Ima Nut and Ima Hooker).

The authors also interviewed adults today who had survived names like Candy Stohr, Cash Guy, Mary Christmas, River Jordan and Rasp Berry. All of them, even Happy Day, seemed untraumatized.

“They were very proud of their names, almost overly proud,” Mr. Sherrod said. “We asked if that was a reaction to getting pummeled when they were little, but they said they didn’t get that much ribbing. They did get a little tired of hearing the same jokes, but they liked having an unusual name because it made them stand out.”

But even if a bad name doesn’t doom a child, why would any parent christen an infant Ogre? Mr. Sherrod found several of them, along with children named Ghoul, Gorgon, Medusa, Hades, Lucifer and every deadly sin except Gluttony (his favorite was Wrath Gordon).

You can sort of understand parents’ affection for the sound of Chimera Griffin, but Monster Moor and Goblin Fester? Or Cheese Ceaser and Leper Priest? What provokes current celebrities to name their children Sage Moonblood Stallone and Speck Wildhorse Mellencamp?

Is it possible — I’m trying to be kind to these humor-challenged fathers — that they think Danger would be a character-building experience? Could there be anything to the paternal rationale offered in Johnny Cash’s song, the one that stopped Sue from killing his father: “I knew you’d have to get tough or die, and it’s the name that helped to make you strong”?

Wait a minute! I even got a mention.

“Researchers have studied men with cross-gender names like Leslie,” Dr. Evans explained. “They haven’t found anything negative — no psychological or social problems — or any correlations with either masculinity or effeminacy. But they have found one major positive factor: a better sense of self-control. It’s not that you fight more, but that you learn how to let stuff roll off your back.”

My conclusion Leslie and Matt? You figure it out.

Read the article here.


  1. Matt

    I think Rod, Hammer and Thor Steel will grow up to be fine (if a bit violent and temperamental) young men.

    Now, Clementine and Beulah Steel? They might be headed to the nursing home immediately following their birth.

  2. Les

    Matt, I know a man with the first name Manish. Why not Manof?

    Then there is always Hardis Steel. I’m still working on girl Steel names.

  3. Matt

    I’ll tell you offline what a few buddies in college used to call me…

  4. Nathan R.

    Matt, does this mean you’re commenting on blogs again?

    As far as names, I would stay away from Ichabod. If it sounds familiar but not quite registering, check out 1 Sam. 4:19-22.

  5. Matt

    I’m steering clear of serious discussions, that’s my rule.

    Don’t worry, I have no interest in naming my child after Mr. Crane.

  6. matrayback

    Hey. I’m the author of Bad Baby Names, the book, this article is about. Thanks for posting about. If you and your readers want to see some other true-but-wacky names, check out my blog, http://www.badbabynames.net.

  7. Les

    Glad to have the credit to you noted. By the way, when I was in 7th grade, we had a boy in class named Henry Bubble Simon. Funny that I can remember that full name after almost 40 years!

    Les

  8. Rob Looper

    What–this isn’t a serious discussion?!

  9. Bill

    It is not appropriate even for a blog but if any of you are interested, ask me in person the name of one of the doctors we had once.

  10. tg

    My favortie is the former govenor of Texas, Govenor Hogg. He named his two daughters Ima and Ura.

Leave a Comment